top of page

The Stories We Tell Ourselves — And How to Stop Letting Them Define Us

Pradeep Ramayya
Apr 21, 2025
6 min read

Updated: Oct 19


You wake up and glance at your phone. There is a message from work, brief and unclear, and almost without thinking, your mind writes a story about what it really means. You don’t reply yet, but the story stays with you, quietly colouring your mood.


A little later you scroll through the headlines, and another story forms: about how bad things are, and how much worse they are about to get.


Then you notice that a message you sent a friend yesterday has been read but not answered. Without any evidence, your mind produces another story: you are unimportant, overlooked, forgotten.


And so it goes on through the day. Small encounters and fleeting moments become raw material for one internal narrative after another. These stories are rarely kind. They are stitched together from rejection, failure, injustice, and looming disaster. They may arrive as a whisper or as an insistent voice, but they almost always feel convincing.


The mind, a master storyteller

The mind is built to make sense of things. Faced with a gap — a silence, a vague comment, a delayed reply — it fills the gap quickly, connecting dots that may never have belonged together. In a dangerous world, that speed kept our ancestors alive. Better to assume the rustle in the bushes is a predator than to wait for proof.


But the same machinery now runs on emails, meetings, family conversations, and social media. It assumes, exaggerates, and dramatises. And because it works so fast, we rarely experience its output as a story at all. We experience it as reality. We don’t think my mind has produced one possible interpretation of this silence. We think she’s annoyed with me.


The story then triggers a feeling — anxiety, anger, hurt — and the feeling seems to confirm the story. I feel anxious, so something must be wrong. Then we act on it. We send the defensive message. We withdraw. We over-apologise. All in response to a story that may not be true.


You are not the stories your mind has written. But until you see them as stories, they will keep writing you.


Mental micro-narratives

Most of the stories that shape our days are not dramatic. They are tiny, half-noticed, and quickly absorbed. Someone talks over you in a meeting: my input doesn’t matter. A partner sighs at their phone: they’re irritated with me. A neighbour mentions their child’s success: mine are falling behind.


I call these mental micro-narratives. Individually, each is trivial. Collectively, they form an atmosphere. By evening you may feel anxious, heavy, or vaguely defeated without being able to point to a single event that explains it. Nothing much happened. But dozens of small stories were quietly added to the load.


Over time, these micro-narratives harden into beliefs about who you are and how the world treats you. I’m not the kind of person who can do that. If I try, I’ll fail. People like me don’t get that kind of success. Beliefs like these become self-fulfilling. We withdraw before we begin, settle before we explore, and never gather the evidence that would prove them wrong.


Stories are contagious

Stories don’t only arise inside us. We catch them from each other.


In many workplaces, someone looks at their list and sighs, ‘I’m so stressed,’ and before long the whole team is using the same word. The workload hasn’t changed. The story about the workload has. Tasks that felt manageable now feel overwhelming, and phrases like if I don’t do it, who will? turn ordinary responsibilities into burdens.


The same thing happens at home and among friends. When the people around us describe life as overwhelming, we tend to mirror their story, feel it ourselves, and reflect it back. A useful question is simply: Is this my story, or have I picked it up from someone else?


The cost of carrying stories

There is a name for what happens when the mind keeps turning these stories over: perseverative cognition. It means continuous, repetitive thinking about worries, past slights, or imagined threats, even when there is no present danger.


Its cost is not only emotional. Research shows that this kind of repetitive thinking keeps the body’s stress response switched on long after the moment has passed: stress hormones stay raised, sleep suffers, and muscles stay tense. It also changes perception. People who ruminate a great deal are more likely to read neutral or ambiguous situations as negative — which produces more stories, which produce more stress.


Catching the story

You can’t stop the mind telling stories; it is part of its design. What you can change is whether you believe the first story it offers.


Start by noticing where fact ends and story begins. There are a few reliable signs that you have crossed the line:


You have jumped from one data point to a whole conclusion. An unanswered message becomes rejection. A small mistake becomes a threat to your career.


You are reading someone’s mind. She thinks I’m incompetent. He’s judging me. Unless someone has told you what they think, your mind is supplying the content.


You are telling the future. This will end badly. I know where this is going. The future can unfold in many ways, but fear usually offers only one.


When you notice any of these, simply name it. My mind is writing the ‘they’re losing interest’ story. Naming creates a little distance. The story may still be possible. But possible is not the same as true.


ARIA: four questions for any story

Once you have caught a story, the four points of the ARIA compass help you decide how much weight it deserves.


Authenticity: Is this story mine? Many of the stories we tell about ourselves were absorbed from others — parents, teachers, culture, an early relationship. Ask: Do I actually believe this, or have I simply always believed it? Would I choose this belief today? A story you have examined and still hold is yours. One you inherited without question may not be.


Resonance: Does this belong to now, or to then? When a story carries more emotion than the moment deserves, it is often borrowing from the past. A friend’s silence stirs an old fear of being forgotten. A colleague’s question echoes a teacher who once made you feel small. Ask: Is this about what is happening now, or about what this reminds me of?


Insight: What do I actually know, and what am I adding? Separate the facts — what a neutral observer would see — from the interpretation layered on top. Then ask: What else could be true? You are not looking for the most comforting story. You are simply loosening the grip of the first one.


Awareness: Am I watching the story, or living inside it? This is the foundation of the other three. When you are inside a story, you believe every word. When you notice it — I’m having the thought that I’ll fail — you have stepped beside it, and from there you can choose whether to follow it.


You won’t need all four every time. Often one question is enough.


Clearing the backlog

Micro-narratives build up quietly, so it helps to clear them regularly rather than letting them accumulate. A few calm minutes at the end of the day — eyes closed, breathing slowly, the busy part of the mind allowed to rest — are enough to look back over the day’s reactions without judgement. Which stories did you pick up today? Which still feel heavy? Run one or two through the four questions, and let the rest go before sleep.

Done regularly, this short reset stops yesterday’s stories becoming tomorrow’s beliefs.


Choosing which stories to keep

The mind will always offer stories. Not every one of them deserves a place in your life.

Left unexamined, these small narratives quietly shape how you see yourself, how you treat others, and how much of your potential you allow yourself to claim. Examined, most of them lose their power. Some turn out to be useful and can stay. Many are simply old, borrowed, or invented, and can be set down.


The stories you choose to believe become the foundation of the life you live. Choose them with awareness, choose them with kindness, and choose them with care.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page